ÍæÅ¼½ã½ã

Alistair Carmichael on US-UK trade deal: "The last thing we can afford now is to treat farming as 'expendable'"

Efra Committee Chair Alistair Carmichel discusses Nigel Farages' backing of chlorinated chicken, Trump's tariffs, a US-UK trade deal and why British farmers need to be backed at all costs in negotiations

clock • 3 min read
Orkney and Shetland MP Alistair Carmichael said: "I cannot truly believe that this Government would be foolish enough to take that step. If they do, however, then the backlash to Farage’s comments last week will look like a storm in a teacup by comparison."
Image:

Orkney and Shetland MP Alistair Carmichael said: "I cannot truly believe that this Government would be foolish enough to take that step. If they do, however, then the backlash to Farage’s comments last week will look like a storm in a teacup by comparison."

In the 1970s, a single word came to define the Tory Government of the time and its attitude towards British fishermen: ‘expendable'.

Prime Minister Ted Heath's Government was locked in negotiations over the UK's entry into the European Economic Community (ECC) and it was determined that our fishing industry was the price to be paid for membership. 

The rest, as they say, is history. In the grand scheme of things joining the EEC was an enormous benefit to the UK economy.

READ NOW: Trump's tariffs unites farmers and businesses behind 'Buy local, Back Britain' campaign

It was also, however, an object lesson in the way that a Government can cast aside an entire industry and the fragile communities that go with it, in the hard yards of trade negotiation.

That should give all of us pause for thought as we watch the Government work toward a potential US trade deal, to reverse the tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump, and perhaps ultimately to allow chlorine-treated chicken and hormone-treated beef onto our supermarket shelves. 

Suggestions have been made that opening up our markets to US food produced to lower standards than are expected of UK farmers could be the price for an exemption to Trump's tariffs. 

LISTEN NOW:

I was baffled – albeit not truly surprised – to hear Reform leader Nigel Farage on the BBC Today Programme acting as the cheerleader for chlorine-washed chicken even before the tariffs were announced.

That is of course pretty typical from Farage, our resident ‘plastic patriot'. 

He was happy to don a Barbour jacket and a flat cap and jump in front of the nearest camera over the tax hike on family farms. 

PLEDGE YOUR SUPPORT: Join ÍæÅ¼½ã½ã's Save Britain's Family Farms campaign

When he has to choose between supporting British farmers or bending over backwards for Donald Trump, however, he shows his true colours.

ÍæÅ¼½ã½ã are rightly proud of the food standards we have in the UK, and so are the British people. 

The last major polling on the issue showed that 80% of the public were opposed to allowing chlorine- or hormone-treated chicken into the UK. 

We have some of the highest food and animal welfare standards in the world and we are not afraid to defend them. That is a lesson that Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and his colleagues may need to be reminded of as well. 

LISTEN NOW: The ÍæÅ¼½ã½ã Podcast: Efra chair Alistair Carmichael - we should not go 'the full French', but farmers' fight is far from over

When I asked the Trade Secretary Jonathan Reynolds in Parliament if he would rule out allowing lower standard US food into the UK, I had hoped it would be a pretty easy ‘yes. 

Instead, he was non-committal.

It is a concession that no previous Government has dared to make – not even the previous Conservative administration, which was no friend to farmers in its trade negotiations. 

I cannot truly believe that this Government would be foolish enough to take that step. 

If they do, however, then the backlash to Farage's comments last week will look like a storm in a teacup by comparison.

The last thing we need is chlorine-treated chicken or hormone-treated beef on our supermarket shelves. 

What we need instead is a strategy for food production in this country that puts farmers and their long-term success at the heart of it. 

In an increasingly dangerous world, domestic food production is more important than it has been in decades – the last thing we can afford now is to treat farming as ‘expendable'. 

Both Farage and the Prime Minister need to get that message into their heads.

LISTEN NOW: The ÍæÅ¼½ã½ã Podcast: Trump, tariffs and tractors – what do US policy moves mean for UK farming?

BNG National Habitat Bank Creation & Unit

£±Ê°¿´¡

Outdoor Beef Finishing Coral System, available

£±Ê°¿´¡

More on Politics

Labour pushing farmers to Nigel Farage and Reform with IHT changes, life peer warns

Labour pushing farmers to Nigel Farage and Reform with IHT changes, life peer warns

Baroness Ann Mallalieu said Labour could fail to gain a second term in office if it loses rural seats due to IHT changes, which could play into the hands of Nigel Farage and Reform UK

clock 13 August 2025 • 3 min read
ÍæÅ¼½ã½ã 'astonished' by Gov's IHT impact assessments

ÍæÅ¼½ã½ã 'astonished' by Gov's IHT impact assessments

HMRC said 275 estates had benefitted from a combined total of £777m in tax forgone due to BPR and APR in 2021 and 2022, but has Gov underestimated the cost of producing food in the UK?

clock 13 August 2025 • 3 min read
Calls for independent review into the value of National Parks

Calls for independent review into the value of National Parks

Do National Parks provide benefits for farming and rural communities?

clock 13 August 2025 • 5 min read